Posted by: tootingtrumpet | October 12, 2010

India vs Australia Second Test Day Four

Man of the Series - well Machine of the Series

The final over of the day.

Ball One – After three Indian innings in the series, Sachin Tendulkar has scored one more run than Gambhir, Sehwag, Dravid, Zaheer, Sreesanth, Dhoni, Harbhajan, Ojha, Sharma and Pujara combined. Still the key wicket after all these years.

Ball Two – What is wrong with Michael Clarke? Looking to defend and consolidate, he was beaten by a good ball from Ojha – no shame in that. But his foot had slid some distance over the crease and he was clearly stumped. Why would a man of his experience make such a schoolboy error?  There may be many reasons, but I suggest that Michael Clarke’s mind is not entirely focused on the matter at hand.

Ball Three – 85-3 and a huge LBW shout from Harbhajan bowling round the wicket to Ponting. At first viewing (and on second viewing) it looked as plumb as plumb gets. Hawkeye predicted that the ball would go on to hit middle two-thirds of the way up. This series has been the best PR for the UDRS one could wish to see. The job was always tough, but it’s too tough with technology available to everyone but the men that matter.

Ball Four – 107-3 and Ponting is hit on the pad. The ball then loops off the back of the bat to where Silly Point should have been. On the fourth and fifth days of Tests on the sub-continent, crazy stuff like that happens, but it doesn’t matter if the close field is absent.

Ball Five – Mike Hussey is out of sorts and when you’re out of sorts, you’re out of luck too. Against a turning ball, he was very fully forward to smother the spin with bat or pad since either will do once the ball turns sharply and there’s so much distance for it to travel between pad and stumps. Unfortunately for him, Gunner Gould had a bit of a guess and gave him out to a ball that turned enough to beat the bat and enough to miss the leg stump. Hussey is no walker, but paused for not a second in getting off the ground once the finger was raised – classy, from a man who must have been crushed with his place under threat.

Ball Six – Ponting, like Tendulkar, is still the key wicket in the Australian line-up. Both these champion batsmen played a lot of Test cricket in the 90s when pitches were more lively and there were many more top class bowlers on the circuit (who weren’t ground down by the treadmill of the current international calendar). There’s much to be said for a harsh upbringing building skills and character – in many walks of life.

You can find the Tooting Trumpet at and on Twitter at @garynaylor999 and @Fakeadil.



  1. Any theories as to what is up with Clarke? He’s clearly not there at the moment.

  2. gg – Bingled?

    • Wouldn’t be the first time the highest ranked batsman in the Australian team failed to fire in India.

      • Hmm. Certainly a concern but he has built up significant credit, and faith, over the last few years. Mind simply not there or not working for him this tour.

        Ashes will give more time to tell but l certainly have more faith in him than other members of the current batting line up.

        Would love to see Khawaja at 6, learning the ropes for a few years before becoming Aus XI next 3.

  3. Once again it must be said – I love test match cricket.

    Great to see some fight out there today.
    We are scoring at 3 an over. Without a spinner to worry India would expect even 220 in 2.5 sessions should be achievable for India. 185 in 3 would be a doddle as need 50 odd overs for it to reverse.

    Would be happy if it came down to 1 session, 50 runs, 5 wickets and a reversing ball.

    Who knows – it could be the George and Pujara show tomorrow.

  4. Maybe we should try this guy?!

    • Isn’t he South African?

      • Must be, if he got a game for England.

  5. Why don’t you leave it until the end of the day to do these evaluations? Ponting and Paine both out now – takes the game out of Aussie hands and leaves it right in the balance.

    Just worth remarking on.

    • A good point Howe-zat, but the idea of the “final over” of the day is not to be summative (as such reports are available on cricinfo and many newpaper sites), but much more impressionistic, capturing thoughts and points as they arise in the day’s play. At Cricket on Five’s website (eg I head up each “ball” with the time – maybe I should do the same here, though I can’t always write contemporaneously.

      The impressions invite comment below by highlighting points that may be lost when the day is finished, but interesting and influential in their own right.

  6. I wonder if Pup isn’t beginning to fear that Punter will never step aside? Gordon Brown syndrome, perhaps.

    • I reckon Pup is quite happy for Punter to keep being captain for a few more years. Specially as he’s unattached!

  7. Fair play by India, batting aggressive to take the possibility of reverse swing out of the equation.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: