Posted by: tootingtrumpet | November 6, 2010

India vs New Zealand First Test Day Three – The final over of the day

Something as old-fashioned as the cricket

Ball One – As has been the pattern in the Tests against Australia, India’s first hour in the field was low intensity stuff, with misfields and general sloppiness the order of the day. But, again following the pattern in the Australian Tests, once the breakthrough came, India were quick to seize the initiative and one wicket brought a second. Quite why India are such slow starters is hard to explain, but their record suggests that they are not hurt by it.

Ball Two – There’s a lot of old-fashioned cricket being played in this match, which pleases this writer. Perhaps the most old-fashioned aspect of the day was Brendon McCullum’s dismissal, drawn forward by Pragyan Ojha who then beat the outside edge for MS Dhoni to effect the stumping. Unlike many of his batsmen-keeper glovemen, Dhoni merely rocked back rather than stepped back which allowed him to whip off the bails quickly. With television showing how much time is lost in gathering the ball and removing the bails in run outs, I’m surprised more isn’t made of keepers’ footwork in stumpings.

Ball Three – One of the many threats to Test cricket is that players growing up playing mainly T20 and one-day cricket will never learn how to build a Test innings. Those fears will recede a little if the considered play of relative youngsters Taylor, Ryder and Williamson is indicative of the new generation of Test batsmen.

Ball Four – Test cricket needs good umpires and, on debut in this match, in Kumar Dharmasena, it may have found one. So far he has got every decision right, including some very tight calls. As importantly, he has radiated calm, not seeking the attention that some of his longer serving colleagues court so assiduously.

Ball Five – Kane Williamson has a laughable bowling action that will soon be referred for reconstruction, but, fortunately, his batting looks easily enough for him to build a long career as an international cricketer. Founded on a solid technique, his concentration, as befits a man with a top score of 192, is excellent. The lad has what it takes to go far and Daniel Vettori has a successor in waiting as batsman and (possibly) captain, if not spinner.

Ball Six – Jesse Ryder has had a troubled start to his international career, but his talent is huge. Until recently, so was his stomach, but with the booze forsook for some time, he looks fitter, if not yet fit and may realise his vast potential yet. I hope so, as he is an exciting cricketer who makes things happen.


You can find the Tooting Trumpet at and on Twitter at @garynaylor999 and @Fakeadil.



  1. Well Dharmasena’s perfect record for the Test just ended! Huge edge missed.

    • David – that sort of thing happens so often with these pieces! It just goes to show how an impression can be formed and then ruined by events!

      • Like saying “Aus surely can’t lose from here”” the other day when SL was 8 for fuck all.
        Used to be Aus could win from anywhere. Now they can lose from anywhere.
        They’ll turn it around. The problems are not so deep.

  2. “As importantly, he has radiated calm, not seeking the attention that some of his longer serving colleagues court so assiduously.”

    Who on earth could you possibly be referring to?! The two recent Indian tests were probably worse for the umpires than they were for Australia.

    • Fred – I agree. There are so many umpires around who should really be keeping a low profile rather than attracting attention. Okay, it’s a very hard job, especially on the sub-continent, but they shouldn’t make it worse for themselves.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: