Posted by: tootingtrumpet | December 17, 2010

Third Ashes Test Day Two – The Final Over of the Day

Johnson (l) and Ponting (r)

Ball One 6.15am – Having missed the first session, I wake up in the aftermath of an England collapse at the hands of a suddenly back in form Mitchell Johnson. Though KP and Trott played poor shots, attacking too early in their innings, the other dismissals were to good balls, for which MJ deserves the lion’s share of the credit.  After lunch, and searching for a five-fer that will revive his career, MJ looks as innocuous as he was in Brisbane – except for the odd unplayable ball. What a curious bowler he is – has any bowler mixed up the sublime and ridiculous so frequently?

Ball Two 6.20am – Australia’s selection for this Test has been radical, with much criticism already attracted by the decision to slot Steve Smith in at Number Six. Totting up the first class runs of Hughes, Smith, Haddin, Johnson, Harris, Siddle and Hilfenhaus gives a figure of 17376. Between them, Bell and Swanny (batting now) have 18965. Do Australians play enough first class cricket to build up the experience? In the past, many greats to be (Hayden, both Waughs, even Hussey, and plenty of others) would play county cricket as part of their development, cranking out first class runs aplenty, but that approach appears to have gone out of fashion.

Ball Three 7.00am – It is widely acknowledged that Test cricket is going through a bit of a slump in terms of the quality of its players in the aftermath of so many greats’ retirements and with other giants of the game into their twilight years. But Test cricket has never been more unpredictable, more fascinating, more thrillingly competitive. England – so on top for so long in this series – are up against it in Perth, while at Centurion, the world’s Number One team (and much the most vaunted batting order in Test cricket) were blown away yesterday by Steyn and Morkel. What next?

Ball Four 8.05am – I’ve never understood why Phillip Hughes has the reputation of being a Sehwagesque flier at the top of the order, since his range of shot is too limited to score quickly against the highest class bowling. He may get in and get a few here, but it’s surprising to see how little progress his game has made since the fast start, and equally fast stall, of his Test career. And, as I write, he plays a schoolboy shot to be caught in an entirely predictable way. Can Australia afford to keep him in the side?

Ball Five 8.30am – The crowd sound subdued, England fans nervous after an unexpectedly difficult day and Australia’s fans not daring to believe that their team are back in The Ashes after their morning newspapers had written them off. If the crowd feel like that, imagine how the players feel! It’s a time for players to confirm or make reputations – good and bad.

Ball Six 8.45am – Signs that the players are understanding the UDRS much better these days. A huge appeal in the fifth over against Watson was turned down on the field and Strauss decided against requesting referral. But an hour or so later, after another not out on the field, Strauss referred a leg-side strangle from Ponting and that was enough to see him off. Batsmen always hop about at Perth, but both Prior and Ponting moved far too much than is required and paid with their wickets – the contrast with the minimal movement of a Tendulkar or Kallis is marked.

The Tooting Trumpet, whom you can often find at and on Twitter at @garynaylor999 and @Fakeadil.



  1. In the past, many greats to be (Hayden, both Waughs, even Hussey, and plenty of others) would play county cricket as part of their development, cranking out first class runs aplenty, but that approach appears to have gone out of fashion.

    The ECB’s tightened up the rules on foreign players, hasn’t it? My understanding is that there’s only one foreigner allowed per team (plus Kolpaks?), and he has to have recently played for his country.

    • Dave – the rules re overseas players change every five minutes and there’s not a lot of money around, but counties would bite the hands off the likes of Smith, Kwhaja and Ferguson, if they wanted to play here.

      • But for every Mike Hussey there is a Marcus North or two.

  2. Re point 5 – I’ve no doubt to locals in the crowd still see the South African’s 4th innnings chase when they shut their eyes at night. If, and it’s a big if, Australia get into a really good position I certainly hope Haddin remembers the mistake he made batting in the second innings and has learnt from it.

  3. Jim – We’re thinking about that SA run chase too! It’s all we have (in this match anyway).

    • Yeah – Mitch announced himself in the first innings in that match and then, well I cannot remember how many wickets he got in the second innings as no one is talking about it! But he was vary good today.
      Also thought (as much as the sky guys think he was lucky) Siddle did his job today. He is and really should only be relied upon to rough up settled batsmen and break partnerships while giving the main bowlers a rest. He manged that wat less than 3 an over plus he got a bonus wicket.

      • I agree Jim, but I do think Siddle needs MJ to be firing. Okay he did well in the first innings in Brisbane, but he looks like a typical English seamer of a kind that typically delivers 25-3-80-2 in Aus, which doesn’t win Tests on its own. But if the strike bowler is 20-2-80-5, then that’s pretty good

        • Both Siddle and Harris are way better than Sreesanth and Ishant though. It was gut wrenching to see the Indian new ball pair waste the opportunity today.

          Three long days to go in both the tests, but both India and Eng have the ability to dig deep. I would be really disappointed if these teams fail to stretch their opponents till Day 5.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: