Posted by: tootingtrumpet | January 19, 2011

South Africa vs India Third ODI – The Final Over of the Day

Not just an ugly face

Ball One 5.15pm – Captains have to find a way to win a cricket match -waiting for something to happen is not a good option. With just 220 on the board, Graeme Smith will look to build pressure, but surely he will need to take wickets as well as squeeze errors out of the Indian batsmen. With a new hard ball in the hands of the Number One rated bowler in the world, Smith set fields that you would expect to see had his batsmen made 100 more runs. Why not try a short leg and a couple more slips? Once the ball goes soft and the quiet middle overs start to tick along with four singles and two dots, the chance will have gone.

Ball Two 5.20pm – South African TV coverage always manages to pick out a little eye candy in the crowd and it’s noticeable today that the Rainbow Nation seems to be fairly well represented on Newlands’ grassy banks. Too much can be read into such pictures of course, but there would be comment if every face in the sell-out crowd were white – and rightly so.

Ball Three 5.30pm – Replays of Dale Steyn’s spectacular catch show that as he completes it and is gathering himself after his leaping dive, the ball comes perilously close to touching the turf. In such circumstances, the catch is almost always accepted as fair, as the fielder is deemed to be in control of his body and the ball – but if so, why give the umpire the chance to call the catch grounded?

Ball Four 5.53 – Morne Morkel, like Glenn McGrath before him, shows the virtue of bowling straight from a high arm on a less than trustworthy pitch. You often hear pundits talking about bowling being too straight the moment the batsman clips the ball through the legside. There may be a case for such criticism in Test matches with a full complement of slips, but in ODIs, it’s surely worth risking a few runs through midwicket for the chance of clattering the stumps. Was Morkel bowling too straight tonight? Ask Rohit Sharma.

Ball Five 6.07pm – Michael Yardy may be an ugly bowler – okay, there’s no maybe: he is an ugly bowler – but Johan Botha demonstrates yet again the tradition of South Africa producing aesthetically displeasing slow men. He’s not in the class of the gruesome twosome of Pauls (Harris and Adams), but his jerky delivery is hardly one for the purists. Effective though, as often as not – alas.

Ball Six 6.22pm – Like many a player picked as a teenager, Wayne Parnell appears to be undergoing a crisis of confidence a couple of years on from debut. Most young players return – often stronger – but a few don’t (Vinod Kambli for example). Parnell may well be disappointed when South Africa name their World Cup squad after this match, but with a lot of work and a little confidence, he has the talent to come back… if he wants it enough.

The Tooting Trumpet, whom you can often find at and on Twitter at @garynaylor999 and @Fakeadil.


  1. Better effective than beautiful, I say…especially if it’s one’s own country. When it comes to the opposition, one would happily prefer beautiful and useless! :)

    2 narrow losses for SA in a row…just a month before the WC…bad time to re-stoke bad memories…

    But as an Indian fan…just loving the fighting spirit of Dhoni’s boys! A few big players missing…no problem, say the rest!

  2. SA are in have major concerns ahead of the world cup…without Kallis they have no balance and have trouble defending and chasing. India are the team to beat…confidence is overflowing. Can’t wait for CWC.

  3. Both the teams tried to throw away the match.The Saffers are slightly better than India in throwing away matches.And so..

    But a very disciplined bowling performance by India to start with, with the exception of Ashish Nehra.

    But what was Raina trying to do, throwing his wicket away, when the chase was under control? And Zaheer Khan did not look like he wanted to stay too.Zaheer survived by sheer luck. And Smith messed up the bowling combination or may be he allowed Pathan’s 3 sixes to mess up his plans.

    Whatever happens in the rest of the ODIs, both these teams have a lot of improvement to do if they stand a chance to win the world cup starting next month.

    May be England’s best chance considering they are a form side (even though in Test Cricket ), and the other top teams are all in disarray?

  4. Well, doesnt that underline the fact that Australia have more than a 50% chance of retaining their crown. None of the pretenders look any good while Aussies, even against a resurgent England with backs to the wall, eked out a superb win. A WC win will also turn around things for Ricky Ponting dramatically – hopefully it will ease the Aussie public into accepting him as test captain again – and I’d like to see what Ian Chappell writes then :-)
    I wonder if Mr Chappell gets enough attention on his shameless u-turns. Not long back, he wrote in cricinfo presenting Ricky as the sole protector of the game’s spirit(let’s face it, even his rabid supporters like me wouldnt claim that) and the only reason World Cricket hasnt fallen back from its gentlemanly roots. Now that Ricky is down, Chappell writes about his indiscretions and poor behaviour.

  5. Enjoying the 4th ODI. Nice to see somebody has edited Johan Bothas wikipedia page

  6. To clarify not condoning it but still amusing none the less

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: