Posted by: tootingtrumpet | February 25, 2011

South Africa vs West Indies – The Final Over of the Day

Super AB hammers the West Indies

Ball One – South Africa are not known for their imagination, and it’s probably not so imaginative to open with Johan Botha’s spin, but credit to Graeme Smith for trying something not quite expected. Chris Gayle can’t have faced spin first up very often and one prod later, he wasn’t facing spin first up any more. Perhaps South Africa will embrace a future comprising eleven davidhusseys too.

Ball Two – It’s orthodox thinking to take the bowling powerplay straight after the mandatory first ten overs, but fielding captains may wish to be more strategic by examining the batting order and identifying batsmen unsuited to powerplay cricket. Come the 25th over, Smith had Sarwan and Chanderpaul new to the crease – surely the ideal time to take the bowling powerplay, but by then it was gone.

Ball Three – Having failed to win five World Cups with pace, South Africa have opted for spin in this match and dismissed the top four West Indies batsmen with the slower stuff. Halfway through their first innings in this tournament is too soon to draw conclusions about the strategy, but it’s looking good so far. Should a side be chosen, not according to the talent available, but according to a formula – eg one hard-hitting opener + one anchor + two hitters + one nurdler + one finisher + one batsman / keeper + one batsman / slow bowler + one slow bowler / batsman + two opening bowlers.

Ball Four – On paper, West Indies have a strong batting line-up, with experience (Gayle, Chanderpaul and Sarwan) complemented by power (both Bravos and Pollard), but there is a lack of belief which manifests itself in a fragility that goes to eleven. Since their long decline from the pinnacle of the game a generation back, no side has looked more likely to lose wickets in bunches – no matter what format of the game.

Ball Five – South Africa started as though they were chasing 223… but in a T20I rather than an ODI. With a West Indies attack not noted for its discipline, why such experienced players as Amla, Kallis and Smith were so keen to get on with it before acclimatising themselves to the pace of the wicket and conditions under lights was beyond my ken. Perhaps the World Cup does things to South Africans – we know it has in the past.

Ball Six – Bad signs for West Indies. Having been in a decent position when Smith and Bravo were motoring, just a few overs later, the initiative was back with the men in green. After knocking over Amla and Kallis cheaply, once again just a few overs, this time from AB de Villiers with the bat, was enough to knock the self-belief out of Sammy’s men. Losing Dwayne Bravo was a blow, but the difference between these sides was much more than one man.

The Tooting Trumpet, whom you can often find at and on Twitter at @garynaylor999 and @Fakeadil.




  1. Not the SA WI game but Bangladesh v Ireland – Where was this version of Tamim Iqbal in the India game?

  2. AB was the AB we’ve come to expect over the last 2 years.

    But for me, the key highlight of the day was Imran Tahir. In my book, SA have just got themselves, for the 1st time, a match-winning spinner. I know the WI batters are poor against spin, but Tahir’s control of length and pace + an excellent wrong one convince me that this man has some class.

    Still have to see how he goes against India and SL (who have the class to attack him successfully)…but I’m excited for SA! Some Pakistani flair might just be the missing ingredient to ensure a happy ending at a World Cup!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: