Posted by: tootingtrumpet | November 13, 2011

The Final Over of the Week in World Cricket November 13 2011

Ball One – The First Test between South Africa and Australia produced two hard fought days of typically tough Test cricket. On a shortened Day One, Australia, led in every sense by Michael Clarke, made 214-8 off 55 overs in tricky, but hardly unplayable conditions. Day Three, also shortened, saw South Africa progress serenely to their target, making 155 runs for the loss of one wicket from 33.2 overs. Day Two – as surely everyone reading this knows – was the cricketing equivalent of the first twenty-four hours of the Battle of the Somme, with 294 runs scored for the loss of 23 wickets. Test cricket is 134 years old and its capacity to surprise is diminished not an iota over 2016 matches.

Ball Two – Dale Steyn, ranked number one in ICC Bowling Rankings for nearly two years, breached the 900 point barrier with his brilliant display at Newlands. Moving the ball through the air and off the seam at extreme pace and with plenty of nous, he has the 17th highest rating ever and is surely worthy of consideration as an all-time great. Amongst currently active bowlers with 100 Test wickets, his career average of 22.96 is almost six runs ahead of the next best (Graeme Swann’s 28.82). Though England’s recent successes have pushed Jimmy Anderson up the bowling lists, the question of who is the best bowler in the world is as settled as it has ever been in my thirty five years watching cricket.

At least one Aussie had a good Test at Newlands

Ball Three – Test cricket needs its chroniclers and they come in many different formats and styles these days (I wrote of some of them prior to The Ashes), but there’s a pleasure to be taken in the old-fashioned report of a day’s play. While Australia’s batsmen weren’t exactly pulling up trees in Cape Town, Greg Baum in the Sydney Morning Herald was peppering the pickets with hit after hit. On Ponting’s travails, he was pithy “He missed what he once would have hit; it was as simple as that. It is now 25 innings since his last century for Australia, and a distant drum is beating.” On Steyn’s menace, he favoured the poetic “Steyn was like an exotic snake, at once beautiful to behold and deadly.” On Day Two’s events, he reached for the apocalyptic “Like an earthquake, there was no forewarning. Like religion, it could not be rationalised. ” And on the impact of the shambolic performance on Australia’s star players, he was damning “Johnson is one of several players whose place will come under critical review between now and the start of the Australian summer. They include Ricky Ponting, Phil Hughes and wicketkeeper Brad Haddin, who had an abjectly poor match. Off-spinner Nathan Lyon bowled only three overs here, but was a victim of circumstances. And he did top-score in Australia’s second innings, so-called.” Read Baum’s majestic reporting in full here.

Ball Four – Not every tall England speedster of the last ten years has shown the fitness or the desire to get on to the paddock and have a bowl. Steven Finn lacks neither fitness nor desire to get on with his job and pitched up at Ragiora, New Zealand to play for Otago in his 43rd match of 2011. He was soon pitching them up too; snaring three Kiwis clean bowled, one LBW and another caught behind. With Ryan Harris and Shane Watson running through the South Africans in their first innings, it was a good week for bowlers who favour attacking the stumps. Perhaps more might try this inexplicably oft-ignored tactic.

Ball Five – As I’m writing this, Peter Roebuck’s death, first reported on Twitter, is confirmed. He was only seven years older than me and I can still see him in my mind’s eye, an awkwardly stiff presence in the glamorous Somerset side of the Seventies and Eighties – Beefy Botham, Big Bird Joel Garner, King Viv, Dasher Denning, The Demon of Frome, Colin Dredge. John Arlott, Jim Laker and Richie would be commentating and I would be desperate for Roebuck to get out to get the stars in. All too soon, I was older and Roebuck was writing all over the media, at times brilliantly, at times eccentrically, even for an Englishman. He had adopted a strange Anglo-Australian accent to give his side of the controversies in which he found himself, making his home Down Under in a country in which he seemed more comfortable, if not actually at ease. And now, only a couple of glides to Third Man after raising his half-century, he is gone. I hope he found peace.

Ball Six – It seems churlish to use the word depressing after writing the previous delivery, but who can read this heading to a scorecard and not wince – for the spectators, the players and the future of cricket in its developing nations:
8th unofficial T20I: Namibia v Kenya at Windhoek, Nov 13, 2011.



  1. Vale Roebuck. He’s been an excellent and long-serving commentator on the ABC here, even more so than his generally good, sometimes better, occasionally worse (Sydney test) writing in The Age. Early reports sound a bit troubling.

    Great pick up on Baum, his Ponting piece and indeed the batting analysis therein, was noted by too few pre the First Test. He’s in really good touch.

    Bring on the kids. We won’t mind losing amidst a true rebuild. Time for several to begin to move on (the great Punter, Haddin, Johnson).

    • I saw Haddin’s shot last night – he looked like a man in shock.

      • Watch it a few times, tooting. It only gets funnier.

        I’ve been reading Greg Baum’s stuff, very good analysis. The second day was great viewing, if startlingly indescribeable.

        • One other thing, I feel very sorry for a man who felt so bad that he took his own life. Never a fan of his writing though.

          • I could like and dislike his writing from piece to piece, almost from par to par. Who knows the working of a mind in turmoil? We may never know his act’s cause.

            • Through the 90s and 00s I would more often than not go to Roebuck’s articles in the Age/SMH before even reading about the matches themselves. I reckon he would have liked the fact you had Greg Baum in two balls before him this week.

              • Reckon he would Jim.

      • Words cannot describe Haddin’s shot. As Lolly says you just have to watch it over and over again. Hardly the first time for him as well.

        Johnson….the returns are simply nowhere near enough. Not remotely. For the sake of form and integrity he must not be played.

        Don’t like this much from Langer. Small minded defensiveness

        l’ve been very frustrated that Usman has not been able to start his career. He has much to learn of course but l look forward to watching him learn it. He has an excellent temperament and we would do well to invest in such players long term. Marsh looks very good. There are some very good kids around, that should see us strong again in the medium term. It matters how we deal with the short term and that transition.

        • If Paine was fit he would no doubt be pressing Haddin hard.

          • Wade should be above Paine fitness or no. He is in fine form at the moment.

        • I can just about understand closing ranks around an old warhorse like Punter, but Hughes? He has not progressed an iota since he was first selected and, like Mitchell, seems unable or unwilling to do anything about it. Having a quirky technique is fine – when it works.

          • They close ranks around everyone. It’s a knee jerk reaction. Now Brad Haddin is saying that he is not going to stop playing his ‘natural game’ and Clarkey is backing him up. You’d think after so much mediocre batting for so long, I mean they rarely get to 300 these days, the penny would have dropped. I can’t work out who is in charge anymore. They seem to be running themselves.

            • New selectors about to come on board. Fingers crossed form, temperament and resilience might begin to matter. Much rather watch the kids lose, at least they might learn something!

              • I’d say the same thing in these circumstances Japal

  2. TT, after our discussion a fortnight ago I finally got to writing a piece on the advantages T20 has over longer forms of cricket in developing nations. Namibia have played (I think) 21 T20 internationals in the past 4 months, and no doubt plan more in the lead-up to the WT20 qualifiers. And who can blame them? They are a very good chance of making the WT20 on recent form and it is their only forthcoming chance to get on the world stage. While for their players, T20 represents by far the best, most lucrative path to professionalism.

    • Good points all Russ, but I’m not sure these players will improve by playing eight T20s against each other.

  3. Hey Gary, some things of interest that add to your points.

    Dale Steyn – now has the second highest strike rate in the history of cricket (this rather juicy stat was uncovered by The Reverse Sweep).

    Peter Roebuck – we had one of the finest writers in cricket today in Gideon Haigh come onto the One Hand One Bounce podcast to discuss the 47 all out test and to remember Peter Roebuck. It might be worth a listen for an insight into him “revolutionising cricket writing in Australia” as Gideon puts it.

    Greg Baum – couldn’t agree more. He is a fascinating writer with adjectives and similes Roebuck would have been proud of.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: